Issues in Nutrition: Including Homemade and Raw Fed Diets
W. Jean Dodds. DVM
The following is a teaching article by Dr Jean Dodds and is used with her kind permission
Nutrition and the Immune System:
Wholesome nutrition is the key to maintaining a healthy immune system and resistance to disease. Commercial foods ingested by animals on a regular basis may not be balanced in terms of major nutrients, minerals and vitamins, and some continue to add chemicals to the final product to enhance its stability and shelf-life. Nutritional deficiencies or imbalances as well as exposures to various chemicals, drugs and toxins present a continual immunological challenge which can suppress immune function, especially in those animals genetically susceptible to immune dysfunction (immune deficiency, autoimmunity, allergies).
Genetic differences between individuals lead to quantitative variations in dietary requirements for energy and nutrient needs, and to maintain health. Also, genetic defects may result in inborn errors of metabolism that affect one or more pathways involving nutrients or their metabolites. While minimal and maximal nutrient requirements have been established for most vitamins and trace mineral elements, optimum amounts for every individual cannot be assumed. Examples of important vitamin and mineral requirements in this regard include vitamin C, vitamin E and selenium, vitamin A, copper and vitamin B-12 . Similarly, a wide variation occurs in the energy needs of dogs depending on their breed, age, sex, and size.
Nutritional factors that play an important role in immune function include zinc, selenium and vitamin E, vitamin B-6 (pyridoxine), and linoleic acid. Deficiency of these compounds impairs both humoral as well as cell-mediated immunity. The requirement for essential nutrients increases during periods of rapid growth or reproduction and also may increase in geriatric individuals, because immune function and the bioavailability of these nutrients generally wanes with aging. As with any nutrient, however, excessive supplementation can lead to significant clinical problems, many of which are similar to the respective deficiency states of these ingredients. Supplementation with vitamins and minerals should not be viewed as a substitute for feeding premium quality fresh and/or commercial pet foods.
Synthetic antioxidants like butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) and butylated hydroxy-toluene (BHT) have been used as preservatives in human and animal foods for more than 30 years. Today, pet food manufacturers may prefer to use ethoxyquin, because of its excellent anti-oxidant qualities, high stability and reputed safety. But significant controversy surrounds issues related to the safety of ethoxyquin when chronically fed at permitted amounts in dog and cat foods. Chemical antioxidants have been linked to inducing or promoting a wide variety of cancers, although the published literature is both disturbing and contradictory in this regard. Toy breed dogs may be particularly at risk because they ingest proportionately more food and preservative for their size in order to sustain their metabolic needs.
Naturally occurring antioxidants (vitamins E and C) are used more commonly in animal foods today, in response to consumer and professional queries about the chronic effects of feeding synthetic chemical antioxidants to pets.
Nutrition and Thyroid Metabolism:
Nutritional influences can have a profound effect on thyroid metabolism. The classical example is the iodine deficiency that occurs in individuals eating cereal grain crops grown on iodine-deficient soil. This will impair thyroid metabolism because iodine is essential for formation of thyroid hormones. Iron and zinc also are important minerals in regulating thyroid metabolism. Another link has recently been shown between selenium deficiency and hypothyroidism. Cereal grain crops grown on selenium-deficient soil will contain relatively low levels of selenium. While commercial pet food manufacturers compensate for variations in basal ingredients by adding vitamin and mineral supplements, it is difficult to determine optimum levels for so many different breeds of animals having varying genetic backgrounds and metabolic needs.
The selenium-thyroid connection has significant clinical relevance, because blood, but not tissue, levels of thyroid hormones rise in selenium deficiency. Thus, selenium-deficient individuals showing clinical signs of hypothyroidism could be overlooked on the basis that blood levels of thyroid hormones appear normal. The selenium issue is further complicated because the synthetic antioxidants still used in some foods to protect fats from rancidity can impair the bioavailability of vitamin A, vitamin E and selenium, and alter cellular membrane function, metabolism and detoxification. Because animals with autoimmune thyroid disease have generalized metabolic imbalance and often have associated immunological dysfunction, it is advisable to minimize their exposures to unnecessary drugs, chemicals and toxins, and to optimize their nutritional status with healthy balanced diets. Families of dogs susceptible to thyroid and other autoimmune diseases show generalized improvement in health when fed premium cereal-based diets preserved naturally with vitamins E and C rather than with the synthetic chemical antioxidants mentioned above. Fresh vegetables cooked with Italian herbs and garlic, dairy products such as yogurt or low fat cottage cheese, or a variety of meats and whitefish can be added.
Nutritional Management (Commercial, Homemade and Raw Food Diets):
Many veterinarians treating animals suffering from immunological diseases appreciate that alternative nutritional management is an important step in minimizing their patient's environmental challenges. The results of this approach have been remarkable. The replacement food must be of good quality and preferably of relatively low protein content (20-22%). Increasing carbohydrate and reducing protein content, while maintaining high quality protein, has been shown to be beneficial for many affected animals and is also believed to have a positive effect on behavior. Diet and behavior appear to be linked because certain highly nutritious foods may aggravate the condition of dogs with behavioral problems (dominant aggression, hyperactivity, and fear). For allergic animals, elimination diets with restricted or novel antigen source are given for 6-12 weeks to evaluate their benefit to the patient. Homemade diets can also be used provided that the formula is properly balanced. All other food supplements, including treats, are withdrawn. Example ingredients that have been used successfully, include whitefish, rabbit, venison, duck, ostrich, emu, buffalo, and turkey mixed with potato, sweet potato and other vegetables (except onions and cruciferous vegetables). Grains are often avoided, at least initially, although novel grains like quinoa, sorghum, barley or flax usually have been well tolerated.
Raw food diets have been gaining in
popularity as well. A key feature of these diets is the variety they provide.
One of the prototype diets [BARF (bones and raw food)] of Dr. Ian Billinghurst
recommends feeding a dog 60% raw meaty bones (chicken backs,wings and necks),
with the rest of the diet composed of ground vegetables mixed with ground
meat, and supplements such as kelp, vitamin E and vitamin C. Nutritional analyses
on some commercially available raw diets suggest that the raw meaty bones
commonly used provide 40-70% protein, and the meat/vegetable mixtures range
from 20-50% protein. The question has arisen about the potential for such
high protein diets to affect renal function when fed continuously, as high
protein diets are reported to induce renal hypertrophy, and increase renal
blood flow and glomerular filtration rate. While this concern may not pertain
to healthy dogs, it could play a role in dogs with previously compromised
renal function. At present, there are no data to support or refute this issue.
Maintaining the appropriate ratio of trace minerals, vitamins, fatty acids and other nutritive elements is especially important for patients with acute and chronic diseases, as their metabolic demands have increased to sustain cell turnover and tissue repair. Typical supplements include: vitamin-mineral mix, antioxidants (vitamins A,C, D, and E and selenium), digestive enzymes, brewers yeast, kelp, honey, coat additives, apple cider vinegar, hydrochloric acid (used sparingly), yogurt, Willard Water, liver, eggs, garlic, and plenty of fresh potable water.
Vitamin A and E have been shown to enhance immune function in small animals, as the former can beneficially influence T-helper responses, and the latter is known to improve both cellular and humoral immunity. Dietary carotenoids, especially lutein and beta-carotene, have been reported to modulate both cell-mediated and humoral immunity in dogs but not in cats.
Raw Food Diet Study:
In collaboration with Dr. Susan Wynn, we investigated the basic clinical laboratory parameters of 256 healthy adult dogs of varying ages and breed types being fed raw food diets for at least 9 months. The same laboratory (Antech Diagnostics) analyzed the samples from 227 of the dogs. From this group, there were 87 dogs fed the classical BARF diet of Dr. Ian Billinghurst, 46 dogs were fed the Volhard diet of Wendy Volhard, and the remaining 94 dogs were fed other types of custom raw diets.
There were 69 dog breeds represented, including 233 purebreds, 16 crossbreds, 1 mixed breed and 6 of unknown breed type. The predominant breeds represented included: 28 Labrador Retrievers, 21 Golden Retrievers and 21 German Shepherd Dogs, 10 Whippets, 8 Shetland Sheepdogs and 8 Bernese Mountain Dogs, 6 Rottweilers, 6 Border Collies, 6 Doberman Pinschers, and 6 German Pinschers, and 5 Cavalier King Charles Spaniels, 5 Australian Shepherds, 5 Borzoi, and 5 Great Danes. Most of the dogs were neutered males (73) or spayed females (85), whereas there were 31 intact males and 32 intact females. Another 6 dogs were of unknown sex. The mean age of the group was 5.67 ± 3.52 years (mean ± SD); and the mean length of time fed a raw food diet was 2.84 ± 2.54 years. The data from this group of dogs were compared to the same laboratory parameters measured at Antech Diagnostics from 75 healthy adult dogs fed a commercial cereal-based kibbled diet. Preliminary statistical comparisons of results for the raw and cereal-based diets found them to be essentially the same with the following notable exceptions:
Higher packed cell volume (hematocrit) in all raw diet fed groups (range of 51.0 ± 6.6 53.5 ± 5.6 %) versus cereal-based kibble (47.6 ± 6.1 %).
Higher blood urea nitrogen (BUN) in all raw diet fed groups (range of 18.8 ± 6.9 22.0 ± 8.7 mg/dL) versus cereal-based kibble (15.5 ± 4.7 mg/dL).
Higher serum creatinine in the Volhard raw diet group only (1.20 ± 0.34 mg/dL) versus cereal-based kibble (1.07 ± 0.28 mg/dL).
While a more detailed analysis of other parameters has yet to be completed, initial results indicate that dogs fed raw meats (natural carnivores) have higher red blood cell and blood urea nitrogen levels than dogs fed cereal-based food (obligate omnivores). Thus, the normal reference values for dogs fed raw food diets should probably be revised.
Wynn S G, Bartges J, Dodds W J. Raw meaty bones- based diets may cause prerenal azotemia in normal dogs. AAVN Nutrition Research Symposium, June 2003 (abstr.).
Dodds W J. Complementary and alternative medicine: the immune system. Clin Tech Sm An Pract, 17(10: 58-63, 2002.
Roudebush P. Ingredients associated with adverse food reactions in dogs and cats. Adv Sm An Med Surg, 15(9): 1-3, 2002.
Dodds W J, Donoghue S. Interactions of clinical nutrition with genetics, Chapter 8. In: The Waltham Book of Clinical Nutrition of the Dog and Cat. Pergamon Press Ltd., Oxford, 1994, p.105-117.
Dodds W J. Pet food preservatives and other additives, Chapter 5. In: Complementary and Alternative Veterinary Medicine. Mosby, St. Louis, 1997; pp 73-79.
Volhard W, Brown K L. The Holistic Guide for a Healthy Dog. Howell Book House, New York, 1995, 294 pp.
Der Marderosian Q A. The Review of Natural Products. Facts and Comparisons, St. Louis, MO, Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins, 2001, pp 389-390, 508-509.
Berry M J, Larsen P R. The role of selenium in thyroid hormone action. End Rev, 13(2): 207-219, 1992.
Burkholder W J, Swecker W S Jr. Nutritional influences on immunity. Sem Vet Med Surg (Sm An), 5(3): 154-156
( From a PDF by Mountain Dog Food)
As is evident all the mean values for both groups of dogs fall within the normally accepted range. A closer look at how these results are interpreted may give more information and help discover why these particular values (Hemocrit, Blood Urea Nitrogen, Creatine) are slightly higher for raw fed dogs.
Hematocrit (Packed Cell Volume): Gives information regarding the amount of red blood cells present in the total blood volume. High levels may indicate dehydration, although this is more of a concern for dogs being fed a dry diet because they often do not consume sufficient volumes of water with their food. Levels below the norm could mean anemia (result of hemorrhage), presence of parasites, or chronic disease
processes (such as liver disease or cancer). Nutritional deficiencies can also cause low levels. Because dogs fed a raw diet receive more adequate levels of protein from animal sources (including iron and B-vitamins) they are better able to facilitate the growth of red blood cells.
Blood Urea Nitrogen (BUN): BUN is produced in the liver from the breakdown of protein and is filtered from the blood by the kidneys. Low levels are commonly seen with low protein diets (I.e. such as the plant proteins primarily used in dry dog food), insufficiency of the liver and anabolic steroid use. High levels are an indication of conditions that reduce the kidneys ability to filter body fluids or those that alter the breakdown of protein. Dogs being fed a raw diet have access to animal based protein sources that have a balanced amino acid profile. It makes sense then that they have higher circulating levels of BUN simply because more amino acids available for the liver to use as an energy source. As indicated from results of human testing high BUN values can occur as a result of eating large amounts of protein rich foods.
Creatinine: A by-product of muscle metabolism that is excreted by the kidneys. High values can indicate kidney disease or urinary obstruction, muscle disease, arthritis, hyperthyroidism and/or diabetes. When we look the results for humans we can see that a diet high in meat content causes transient elevations of serum creatinine. One indication of a normally functioning kidney is consistent creatinine values over time. This reiterates why it is important for raw fed dogs to have a series of results to compare against. Although the values may be on the higher end of normal, if they are consistently in the same range this indicates that kidney function is normal. It is commonly thought that a different set of normal values should be developed for raw fed dogs. These slightly higher blood values are to be expected simply because these indicators are a measure of protein breakdown/metabolism and raw fed dogs receive a higher percentage of readily digestible and balanced animal protein in their diets. It may be valuable for your pet to have successive laboratory results from previous years in order to determine what is normal for your dog.
Useful information on how to read bloot tests can be found at http://home.gci.net/~divs/disease/lab_tests.html
Page last update: 05/30/2011